Last week I “complained” that the recipe is at the bottom of the page. I left out the other half of the joke. Before you can even start scrolling for the chicken, you have to get past the top.
Open a news article on your phone and count. A consent banner asks what you will allow. A second screen offers to let you skip the tracking for a monthly fee. A newsletter box slides up. The browser asks whether this site may send you notifications. A banner suggests you would be happier in the app. Then the meter tells you that you have two free articles left, and a video starts playing in the corner. Somewhere under all of that is the first sentence.
The recipe page is built to hold your attention. The top of the page is built to collect something from you before you have read a word. Each layer has a customer, and almost none of them is the reader.
Who is Each Layer For?
Here is the stack, layer by layer, with the person it serves:
- The consent banner is for the ad-tech supply chain. Its job, legally, is to ask permission. In practice, its job is to get a “yes.”
- The “pay or accept” screen is for the publisher’s revenue team. It turns privacy into a product tier.
- The newsletter modal is for the marketing team. An email address is a first-party identity that survives cookie clearing.
- The “disable your ad blocker” wall is for the advertisers whose ads you were blocking.
- The notification prompt is for the audience team, which wants a channel to your lock screen.
- The meter or paywall is for the subscriptions team, and it is the only layer that is honest about what it wants.
I don’t think any single layer is outrageous. Together, they make a toll booth with six windows, and you pay at each one in clicks, attention, data, or money.
The Banner Is a Design Choice, Not a Law
People usually blame Europe for cookie banners. The EU’s ePrivacy rules do require consent before a site stores non-essential trackers on your device. But the law asks for a choice. It does not dictate a giant blue “Accept all” button and a grey “Manage options” link that leads to 40 toggles.
That design came from industry. As Max Schrems of the privacy group noyb puts it, “Cookie banners are not an invention of data protection, but of the tracking industry” (as quoted in PPC Land, 2026).
The research backs him up. When Midas Nouwens and colleagues at Aarhus, UCL, and MIT scraped consent pop-ups on 10,000 popular UK websites, only 11.8% met minimal requirements based on European law. Most made it substantially harder to reject tracking than to accept it (Nouwens et al., 2020).
Regulators have noticed. In January 2022, France’s data protection authority, the CNIL, fined Google €150 million and Facebook €60 million because “several clicks were required to refuse all cookies, against a single one to accept them” (Arntz, 2022). The fine was not about using cookies. It was about the shape of the button.
If you work in IT, you know this pattern. A control that is technically present but practically unusable is not a control. It is a checkbox for the auditor.
Pay or Be Tracked
The newest layer is the one that matters most for this blog. Under “consent or pay,” a site offers two doors: accept tracking for free, or pay a fee to read without it. Meta rolled this out across the EU in late 2023, and a growing number of news sites offer the same deal.
In The Toll for Truth, I argued that people who can’t pay for the verified record still pay in other currencies (Konderla, 2026). Consent or pay makes that literal. The subscriber gets the article and their privacy. Everyone else gets the article and a tracking profile. It is a paywall with a second price list.
European regulators are skeptical. In April 2024, the European Data Protection Board said that for large online platforms, a choice between behavioural-ad consent and a fee will “in most cases” not produce valid consent, and that a paid alternative alone “should not be the default way forward” (Lomas, 2024). In April 2025, the European Commission fined Meta €200 million, the first fine under the Digital Markets Act, for failing to give users an effective choice (Horn & Nagel, 2025).
That opinion was aimed at the giants, not at your local paper. But the question it raises applies to everyone: is it really consent if the alternative is a bill?
The Wall That Asks You to Lower Your Shields
The “disable your ad blocker” wall deserves its own paragraph, because it asks readers to switch off a security control.
Ad blockers are partly a defense against malvertising, the practice of slipping malicious code into ad networks. In January 2016, Forbes asked visitors to turn off their ad blockers to read its “30 Under 30” list. A security researcher who complied was “immediately served with pop-under malware, primed to infect their computers” (Masnick, 2016).
That was ten years ago, and ad networks have improved. But the trade is still lopsided. The publisher gets the ad impression. The reader takes on the risk of whatever the ad network failed to catch. And the readers most likely to click “OK, I’ll disable it” are the ones least likely to have anything else protecting them.
The Time Tax, Paid Up Front
In the recipe post, I called the cost of the free path a time tax. The top of the page is where the tax is collected first.
The privacy policy is the long version of the cookie banner. In 2012, Aleecia McDonald and Lorrie Faith Cranor estimated that actually reading the privacy policies of the sites you visit would take about 250 working hours a year, roughly 30 full working days, and cost about $781 billion a year in time nationally (Sydell, 2012). Nobody does that, of course. The banner exists because nobody does that. It compresses a policy you won’t read into a button you will press, and the design makes sure you press the right one.
So the tax is split. People with time can open “Manage options” and switch off 40 toggles. People with money can pay to skip the tracking. Everyone else clicks “Accept all” on a phone at the bus stop, and pays in data.
The Fix That Almost Was
There is a technical answer, and Europe nearly adopted it. In November 2025, the European Commission’s Digital Omnibus proposal would have let people set their consent choice once, in the browser, and required sites to respect that machine-readable signal. In the original text, media service providers were exempt (PPC Land, 2026).
On June 18, 2026, the Council of the EU removed the browser-signal provision from its position. It kept a smaller rule: after you refuse, a site may not ask you again for the same purpose for at least six months (Kollnig, 2026). As of this writing, the European Parliament still has not taken a position on the signal, so it is not dead yet.
Here is the uncomfortable part. One argument against the browser signal was that it would cut advertising revenue for news and media companies (Kollnig, 2026). Kollnig argues that fear was “stoked by Google,” which commissioned a study estimating €40 to €50 billion a year in advertiser revenue at stake, figures noyb disputes (PPC Land, 2026). But it is not a made-up worry. The free tier of the news is ad-funded, and I have spent two series saying the free tier matters. The banner is annoying partly because it is load-bearing.
That is the same trap as the recipe page. The reader isn’t the customer, so the reader’s experience is whatever is left over after the customers are served.
Getting to the First Sentence
A few things help in the meantime:
- Click “Reject all” when it is offered. It usually works the same as “Accept,” and every reject is a data point publishers see.
- Let a tool answer for you. Consent-O-Matic, a free browser extension from the Aarhus researchers behind the Nouwens study, fills in many consent pop-ups with your preferences automatically.
- Send a signal anyway. Global Privacy Control is a browser setting that tells sites not to sell or share your data. Some US states, including California, require sites to honor it.
- Don’t lower your shields for a stranger. If a site you don’t know asks you to disable your ad blocker, leave. If it is a site you trust, subscribe or allowlist that one site.
- Pay the outlets you rely on, or use your library. A subscription buys the article without the data price, and many public libraries offer news databases for free.
The recipe is at the bottom, the cookie banner is at the top, and the article is in the middle, if you can get there. Next time I want to put a number on how long that takes.
Sources
- Arntz, P. (2022, January 7). Google and Facebook fined $240 million for making cookies hard to refuse. Malwarebytes Labs. https://www.malwarebytes.com/blog/news/2022/01/google-and-facebook-fined-240-million-for-making-cookies-hard-to-refuse
- Horn, S., & Nagel, S. M. (2025, April 24). Meta fined 200 million euro by EU under Digital Markets Act. Taylor Wessing. https://www.taylorwessing.com/zh-hant/insights-and-events/insights/2025/04/meta-fined-200-million-euro-by-eu-under-digital-markets-act
- Kollnig, K. (2026, July 14). Digital Omnibus proposal could finally end Europe’s cookie banner problem. Tech Policy Press. https://techpolicy.press/digital-omnibus-proposal-could-finally-end-europes-cookie-banner-problem
- Konderla, J. (2026). The Toll for Truth: Paywalls, information deserts, and the asymmetric web (v1.0). Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23131192
- Lomas, N. (2024, April 17). EU privacy body adopts view on Meta’s controversial ‘consent or pay’ tactic. TechCrunch. https://techcrunch.com/2024/04/17/edpb-consent-or-pay-opinion/
- Masnick, M. (2016, January 11). Forbes site, after begging you to turn off adblocker, serves up a steaming pile of malware ‘ads’. Techdirt. https://www.techdirt.com/2016/01/11/forbes-site-after-begging-you-turn-off-adblocker-serves-up-steaming-pile-malware-ads/
- Nouwens, M., Liccardi, I., Veale, M., Karger, D., & Kagal, L. (2020). Dark patterns after the GDPR: Scraping consent pop-ups and demonstrating their influence. Proceedings of CHI 2020. https://arxiv.org/abs/2001.02479
- PPC Land. (2026, June 28). EU Council drops cookie signal after Google lobbying: €40–50bn at stake. https://ppc.land/eu-council-drops-cookie-signal-after-google-lobbying-eur-40-50-bn-at-stake/
- Sydell, L. (2012, April 19). To read all those web privacy policies, just take a month off work. NPR. https://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2012/04/19/150905465/to-read-all-those-web-privacy-policies-just-take-a-month-off-work

